November 19, 2026
When you hire an eCommerce agency, it's natural to want a team that listens to you and gets things done. That matters, of course. But the agencies that add the most value to your business are often the ones that are willing to ask "why?" before they start building.
An agency that agrees to everything might feel easy to work with at first. Over time, though, saying yes to every request can lead to an overcomplicated website, a stretched budget, and features nobody uses. A good partner will respect your knowledge of your business while bringing its own experience of what works, and sometimes that means questioning a decision before it becomes expensive.
In this article, we look at whether you need an eCommerce agency for your Magento, Adobe Commerce or Shopify store, the things a good agency should challenge you on, and how to tell whether an agency will do that before you sign.
Do you need an eCommerce agency for your Magento, Adobe Commerce or Shopify store?
Not every business needs an agency straight away. If you're just starting out with a straightforward catalogue, you may be able to manage most changes yourself or with a freelancer, whichever platform you're on.
An agency tends to make more sense as your store becomes more complex. Growing stores often connect to ERP, warehouse, CRM and payment systems, so a change in one place can affect several others. At that point, you need more than someone who can write code. You need a team with experience across development, UX, performance, security and ongoing support and maintenance, who can see how each decision affects the rest of the store.
Some businesses also work with an agency alongside their own in-house developers. In that set-up, an experienced Magento development partner can add specialist knowledge, extra capacity for big projects and a second opinion on technical decisions. We've written more about the benefits of working with an external developer if you're weighing this up.
What should a good eCommerce agency challenge you on?
A good agency won't question everything, and it shouldn't. But there are some areas where a well-timed question can save you a lot of time, money and frustration.
What you're trying to achieve
Before talking about features, a good agency should ask what you want the project to achieve. More sales, a higher average order value, fewer customer service calls or less admin for your team will each lead to a different set of priorities. If a request doesn't support any of those goals, it's worth asking whether it needs to be done at all.
What your customers need
It's easy for a website to end up reflecting the preferences of the people who run it rather than the people who shop on it. A good agency will ask what your analytics, search data and customer feedback show, and suggest UX research or conversion rate optimisation (CRO) testing where the answer isn't clear.
Scope and priorities
Most wish lists are longer than the budget allows. Rather than trying to deliver everything at once, a good agency will help you decide what has to be in the first release and what can wait. Launching with fewer features that work well, then improving based on how customers use the site, is usually a safer approach than a long project that tries to do everything.
Whether you're on the right platform
The right platform depends on your business, not on what an agency happens to specialise in. A good agency will tell you if Shopify would serve you better than Magento, or if you're paying for Adobe Commerce features you don't use. Our Shopify and Magento comparison covers some of the questions worth asking.
Extensions, apps and custom code
Every extension, app and piece of custom code adds something you'll need to maintain, update and test. A good agency will ask whether a feature can be handled with existing configuration or a well-supported extension or app before building something bespoke, and will help you keep your Magento extensions or Shopify apps to the ones your store needs. As we've covered in our article on why you still need an experienced developer, knowing what not to build is as important as knowing how to build it.
Budgets and timelines
If a deadline or budget looks unrealistic, it's far better to hear it at the start of a project than halfway through. A good agency will explain the trade-offs clearly, whether that's reducing the scope, phasing the work or allowing more time, so you can make an informed decision.
Looking after the store after launch
Your website will need ongoing care long after it launches. A good agency will ask how you plan to handle security patches, platform upgrades, performance and support, and will challenge you if there's no plan in place, because a store that isn't maintained becomes harder and more expensive to look after over time.
How can you tell whether an agency will challenge you?
It can be hard to judge from a proposal alone, so it helps to pay attention to how an agency behaves during the early conversations. These questions can help when you're choosing an eCommerce agency.
Did they ask about your business before talking about features? An agency that wants to understand your customers, margins and goals first is more likely to question requests that don't support them.
Have they ever recommended against something? Ask for an example of a time they advised a client not to build a feature, change platform or add an extension, and what happened as a result.
Do they specialise in your platform? A specialist Magento agency or Shopify agency will know the platform's strengths and limits well enough to tell you when a request is likely to cause problems.
How do they handle disagreement? Ask how they would respond if you insisted on something they didn't recommend. A good answer explains the risks clearly, then respects your decision.
What happens after launch? Find out what support, maintenance and ongoing improvement they offer, and how they would decide what to work on next.
Our article on what to look for in a web design agency covers some of the other practical points worth checking, such as portfolio, budget and communication.
Finding an agency that works with you
The best agency relationships feel like a partnership. You bring the knowledge of your business, products and customers, and your agency brings experience of what tends to work, what tends to go wrong and how to avoid the most expensive mistakes. A little healthy challenge in both directions is a sign that the relationship is working.
At Develo, we've been building and supporting eCommerce stores since 2010, and we work with Magento, Adobe Commerce and Shopify merchants every day. If you're looking for an agency that will take the time to understand your business and give you a straight answer, even when it isn't the one you expected, get in touch with the Develo team. We'd be happy to talk through your plans.
Last updated: November 19, 2026
